We need

Why do we need more fish in EU seas ?

In the European Union, fishing fleets have been managed by the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) for almost 50 years. However, from the mid 1990s fish populations started to severely decline and trends in overfishing became alarming. Then, the CFP started progressively to integrate sustainability as an objective and, in 2013,  to set targets to maintain fish populations at sustainable levels.

Despite some progress in the last decade, today most of the fisheries resources and marine ecosystems are in a bad condition.The depletion of fish stocks has not only a major impact on marine biodiversity, but also on the future of fishers and fisheries whose income depends on these resources. 

There is an urgent need for more ambitious measures that would benefit EU society and nature as a whole.

The EU did not meet its targets

2020 was supposed to be the year of biodiversity at the international level. It was also supposed to be the year when good environmental status of EU seas was to be achieved and when all fish stocks were to be exploited at sustainable levels. These targets are part of the european legislation but EU action has been slowed down by short term interests and a lack of progress in the implementation process.

The situation of EU seas is grim

In the last decades, there were some improvements for fish populations in the Atlantic Ocean where the CFP is starting to bear fruit. Scientists estimate that around 38% of the stocks assessed are overexploited.

But the situation is very worrying in the Mediterranean Sea, where more than 80% of fish stocks are overexploited. Let us also be reminded that these figures are calculated species by species without taking into account marine ecosystems in their entirety, and only where the respective scientific assessments are available.

The European Court of Auditors confirmed this trend: EU action in the past decade was insufficient for the recovery of marine ecosystems and habitats. In general, levels of pollution are alarming and climate change has growing impacts on our oceans.

What can we do to protect fish populations and marine biodiversity ?

The good news is that if we act now, we can change that future and have healthy oceans, according to some scientists. The EU should therefore put an end to overfishing.

This starts by fully implementing the 2013 reform of the CFP, by setting fishing quotas in line with sustainability criterias from all stocks, in all EU seas. We need to reinforce the scientific knowledge of our stocks, making sure enough resources are allocated to study all fish populations and the interactions between the different species and marine ecosystems they live in. This is key to implementing an ecosystemic approach to fisheries policy. We also need to limit the use of the most destructive fishing techniques, such as all gear that comes into contact with the seabed and so-called Fish Aggregating Devices, as it has been proven they have very negative consequences on the marine environment.

To actually protect marine biodiversity, the EU should set an effective network of Marine Protected Areas, covering 30% of EU waters with real management plans and a high level of protection for at least 10% of EU waters, meaning areas where all catches and economic activities are prohibited. According to the European Environmental Agency (EEA), today less than 1% of European Marine Protected Areas are fully protected and integrate fishing bans as part of their management measures. It is time for the EU to put an end to so-called “paper parks”. The 30% target is greenwashing if no measures are taken in these areas, such as bans of destructive fishing techniques or other economic activities

This year as part of the EU Green Deal, the European Commission adopted the 2030 EU Biodiversity Strategy: a comprehensive roadmap with ambitious targets such as 10% of highly protected areas. Ambitious targets set in the 2030 Biodiversity Strategy must be enshrined in EU legislation and fully implemented. Conservative forces are trying to turn this back.

What can you do ?

2021 will be decisive for marine biodiversity. We need your support to make the voice of oceans and small-scale fishers heard in the European Parliament ! The own-initiative report “More fish in the Seas” of Caroline Roose, which pushes for ambitious measures, will be voted in the European Parliament’s plenary session next week.

Tweet to those MEPs that have not yet pledged to support ambitious measures to get more fish in the seas.

Key figures

  • At the global level in 2012 it was estimated that $83 billion in lost profits due to overfishing will be lost, of which $12.5 billion will be in Europe (World Bank 2012)
  • In 2020, only 6% of assessed fish stocks in the Mediterranean were fished at sustainable levels (European Environmental Agency 2020)
  • Last December, EU fisheries ministers set quotas and reduction of fishing efforts at levels exceeding scientific advice. In the Atlantic Ocean, 35% of the quotas were set above sustainable levels. For the Mediterranean Sea, national governments rejected the proposal for a 15% reduction in the fishing effort of trawlers and only adopted a reduction of 7.5%.
  • 12% of European waters are designated as MPAs, but only 1.8% have a management plan.
  • According to the European Environmental Agency, less than 1% of the EU marine protected areas have high level of protection (EEA 2020)
  • 59% of EU Marine Protected Areas are commercially trawled at levels higher than non-protected areas (European Court of Auditors 2020)
  • Only 0.23% of the Mediterranean Sea is totally and highly protected. (CNRS 2020)
  • The Mediterranean region warms 20 times faster than the rest of the globe. By 2050, climate change could lead to local extinction of more than 20% of commercial fishery species of the Mediterranean Sea (MedEC Mediterranean Experts on Climate and environmental Change 2020).

Or go deeper